Wednesday, June 12, 2019

An Unsettling Decision from Louisiana on Inspection of Books and Records


An Unsettling Decision from Louisiana on Inspection of Books and Records

      A recent decision from the Louisiana Supreme Court, in a perhaps troubling decision, held that the executor of the estate of a deceased member of an LLC has limited rights to inspect the LLC’'s books and records. Succession of McCalmont, No. 2019-C-0359, 2019 WL 2181408 (La. May 20, 2018).
      In the decision of the Louisiana Court of Appeals, it assessed a pair of operating agreements and the LLC Act to determine whether the executor of the estate of an individual member in several LLCs could inspect the LLC’s books and records. Applying that law, the Court of Appeals held that the executor did not have a right to inspect the books and records even as it acknowledged that this could place the executor and any other successor in a Catch-22 situation, namely an entitlement to receive distributions when and as made even as there are no information rights with respect to what those distributions should be. As to that point, the Court of Appeals noted:
We further note that the law as written allows for the creation of situations whereby an assignee of a deceased member's rights, while due distributions, may never be able to see company records to ensure he is actually receiving those distributions in full, because remaining members can simply withhold records that would show what, if anything, may be owed. However, the Limited Liability Companies Act and the limited jurisprudence dealing with the transfer issue before us clearly limit what Jay, as an assignee, is entitled to. While Jay and the estate may be entitled to distributions from the LLCs, they are not entitled to the records which they seek.
Succession of McCalmont, 2018 WL 6521176, *8 (La. App., Cir. 3, Dec. 12, 2018).
      The Louisiana Supreme Court would in part reverse, holding that the executor has the right “to inspect the records of the limited liability companies in which Ms. McCalmont had an interest in so far as those records arose prior to the date of her death.”
       One justice, concurring, suggested that the executor should have the right to inspect all books and records of the LLC, whether arising before or after the date of death.
      For myself, this decision is troubling. Notwithstanding the circumstance suffered by the executor as identified by the Court of Appeals, that is the natural consequence of treating the estate as the assignee of the decedent. It is just as much a stranger to the LLC as is any other third-party. If the legislature believed that “death is a sufficiently high transaction cost to preclude abuse” such that inspection of books and records by an estate should be permitted, it could have easily written that in the statute. It did not. If the members of the LLC thought that the estate of a deceased member should be entitled to inspect books and records, that could easily have been written into the operating agreement. In this instance, that was not done. To afford the executor of a member’s estate the right to inspect the LLC’s books and records as they existed prior to the date of death is equivalent to saying that an assignee of a membership interest has the right to inspect the books and records for the period before the assignment. That is, however, antithetical to what has always been the law of unincorporated business organizations. Some LLC Acts, an example being that of Massachusetts (see M.G.L.A. 1526 C § 42), provide that the estate of a member has the rights of a member. Louisiana could have adopted a statute to that effect. It did not. It seems inappropriate for the court to be creating rights that were at least implicitly rejected in the drafting of the controlling statute.

Tuesday, June 11, 2019

Removing a Bad Business Partner


Removing a Bad Business Partner

      Ladd Hirsch, in his blog Winstead Business Divorce, has posted a short article titled Partnership Blues: Can a Bad Business Partner Be Removed by the Company’s Majority Owner When No Buy-Sell Agreement Exists?    HERE IS A LINK to that article.

Business Courts - They Are Coming to Kentucky

Business Courts - They Are Coming to Kentucky


      On Friday, June 14, at the KBA Annual Convention, the KBA Section of Business Law will be presenting Business Courts - They Are Coming To Kentucky.
      Pursuant to an order of the Kentucky Supreme Court, there is being launched, on a pilot program basis, a business court docket in Jefferson County Circuit Court. Judges Cunningham and Bisig will be the initial judges assigned to this docket.
      At this two-hour program, our panel will review the path by which the business court docket has come into existence and as well consider a variety of topics that remain under discussion including the special rules applicable with respect to the business court docket and the criteria for designating cases to that docket. There will also be consideration of how business courts/dockets have developed across the country. We anticipate ample opportunity for questions from the audience.
      Presenting on Kentucky’s new business court docket will be, from the Kentucky Supreme Court, Chief Justice John D. Minton, Jr. and Deputy Chief Justice Lisabeth Hughes. They will be joined by Jefferson County Circuit Court Judges Angela McCormick Bisig and Charles Cunningham and by Judge James L. Gale from the North Carolina Business Court. Kenly Ames of English Lucas Priest & Owsley, LLP will serve as the moderator.
      This presentation will be held on Friday, June 14 commencing at 10:10 and concluding at 12:20 (there will be a 10 minute break in the program). It will take place in the French Room at the Galt House Hotel.

Monday, June 10, 2019

Business Law Update: Cases (and a Few Statutes) of Which You Need To Be Aware

Business Law Update: Cases (and a Few Statutes) of Which You Need To Be Aware

      On Thursday, June 13, at the KBA Annual Convention, the KBA Section of Business Law will be presenting Business Law Update: Cases (and a Few Statutes) of Which You Need to be Aware.
      This Business Law Update is designed to bring attendees up to speed on the most important cases handed down by Kentucky and other courts over the last two years. The developments being reviewed are important for both the business law practitioner and the business law litigator. While there will not be time to review every case in the voluminous outline, presenters Elizabeth M. Reeder and Thomas E. Rutledge will highlight particular decisions. In addition, their presentation will address a number of cases that have come down after the due date for the outline.
      This presentation will be from 3:45 through 4:45 in the French Room.

Improbability in Determining When a Firm is Insolvent


Improbability in Determining When a Firm is Insolvent

 
            A firm, whether it be a LLC, an LLP or a general partnership, may not make distributions to its owners when it is insolvent.  If and to the extent distributions are made when the firm is insolvent, they may be “clawed back” into the firm for satisfaction of creditor claims.

            According to a story published today in Law360, a settlement of the claims against the partners has been reached.  As reported, there were alternative dates at which a determination of insolvency could be made.   The amount of the settlement is less than the full amount that would be due if the earlier date were used, but more than the amount that would be due if the later date were used.

The article is Sedgwick Strikes Clawback Deal With Former Equity Partners, by Emma Cueto, Law360 (June 7, 2019).

Saturday, June 8, 2019

The Raid on Lindisfarne


The Raid on Lindisfarne


      Today marks the anniversary of the Viking raid on the Abbey of Lindisfarne in 793.  An important ecclesiastical site found in the 630s .  While this was not the first time the “Vikings” had raided England, the destruction suffered by the Abbey is used as the beginning date of the Viking Age.  The Abbey would survive the raid, but by the time of the Dane Law was abandoned, the monks moving to Durham.  The monastery was reestablished in 1093 and flourished until the Dissolution of the Monasteries under Henry VIII.

 

      A word on “Vikings” is in order.  It is not a reference to a people.  The Vikings would originate from what are today Denmark, Norway and Sweden.  Like almost all people of the era, they were farmers, hunters and fishermen.  They lived under a variety of petty kings and lords tied together by any number of different allegiances even as they engaged in raiding and warring against one another.  From the late 8th Century, utilizing newly developed ship technology, these peoples began to raid outward.  Hence the raids upon England and later into Northern Europe.  The “Vikings” were the men (whether women participated as “shield maidens” remains in dispute) who went on the raids.  Hence, Viking is a job description.

 

     Today is as well the anniversary of another book-end of the Viking Age.  On this day in 1042 Harthacnut, King of England and son of Cnut the Great, died. He was the last king of England from Denmark.  He was succeeded by Edward the Confessor, a king of English heritage.  Of course Edward’s death in 1066 would lead to turmoil over the succession, leading ultimately to the victory of William the Bastard at the Battle of Hastings (whereupon he became William the Conqueror).

Thursday, June 6, 2019

Dean Murphy to Receive the Nathaniel R. Harper Award

Dean Murphy to Receive the Nathaniel R. Harper Award
I need to do a shout out to my friend Daniel P. Murphy, Jr., Assistant Dean for Community Engagement & Diversity at the University of Kentucky College of Law. He is to receive the Nathaniel R. Harper Award from the Kentucky Bar Association. This Award recognizes:
The Award seeks to recognize those individuals or organizations that have demonstrated a commitment to changing the face of the Kentucky Bar by promoting full and equal participation in the legal profession through the encouragement and inclusion of women, minorities, persons with disabilities, members of the lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgendered community and/or other underrepresented groups.
Congratulations Danny.