Monday, October 20, 2025

The Separateness of a Corporation from Its Shareholders

                                           The Separateness of a Corporation from Its Shareholders


In a recent decision, the Kentucky Court of Appeals was called upon to address and apply the principle that a corporation is separate and distinct from its shareholders to the effect that the shareholders may not exercise the corporation’s rights. While no doubt the correct rule, as is the parallel rule that an LLC and its members are distinct from one another, the opinion is more muddled than it needed to be in describing the contract at issue and who were its parties. Still, by the end the story becomes clear. Pinski v. Levine, 2025 WL 2422598 (Ky. App. Aug. 22, 2025).

First, the cast of characters. Our plaintiff is Anne Pinski, a podiatrist. Next we have Robert Levine, also a podiatrist, who, in the course of this litigation would pass away and be thereafter represented by his executor, his widow Sharon Levine. Last there is Podiatric Physicians of Kentucky, PSC (PPK), a professional services corporation organized in Kentucky.

The contract at issue provided that Pinski would be brought out of the corporation for $205,000 paid in three unequal installments. The confusion that arises in the case is to who were the parties to that purchase agreement. It is described in the second paragraph of the opinion as “Pinski, Levine, and PPK entered into a stock purchase, separation, and general lease agreement.” The opinion goes on just thereafter to state “upon execution of the Agreement, Levine paid the first installment of $102,500.” Still later in the opinion it is recited that “Under the terms of the Agreement, Levine, individually, agreed to purchase Penske‘s shares of stock in PPK.” (2025 WL 2422598, *3), apparently to the effect of an exclusion of PPK from the transaction. But that is what seems to be the crux of the case.

After the agreement was entered into and the first payment had been made, Penske cash four checks against the PPK’s account in the total amount of $16,500; she had written these checks to herself before the execution date of the agreement by which her shares were bought out. In addition, it was alleged that she had taken with her certain office equipment. In response Levine offset $21,500 from the next installment paid to Pinski.  To which she took umbrage.

The trial court held that the offset was proper (see 2025 WL 2422598, *2), and this appeal followed. 

It is only at this point in the opinion that the actual terms of the agreement at issue come out, namely that Levine agreed to buy the PPK shares from Pinski, and that PKK was not an obligor under the agreement.

Under the terms of the Agreement, Levine, individually, agreed to purchase Pinski’s shares of stock in PPK for $205,000 and was to make three installment payments to Pinski. After making the first installment payment of $102,500, Levine did not make the full second installment payment of $50,000; rather, he subtracted or set off $21,500 from the amount owed in the second installment.

To justify the setoff, Levine claimed that in January 2012, Pinski wrote checks on the PPK checking account to herself without disclosing same and waited to cash the checks until after execution of the Agreement in March of 2012. These checks totaled $16,500. Levine also claimed that Pinski took an x-ray machine owned by PPK, which together with the checks totaled $21,500. 2025 WL 2422598, *3.


Which leads into a discussion of corporate separateness and that Pinski’s alleged wrongful acts against PPK were not against Levine.

PPK was a professional service corporation and was incorporated under KRS 274.015. As a professional service corporation, PPK was a separate legal entity from its shareholders. On this point, the law is clear that a corporation and its shareholder are not to be considered legally interchangeable but are separate and distinct legal entities. PPK was also a separate party to the Agreement.  Id. (citations omitted).

Which when applied to the facts yields:

It is uncontroverted that PPK owned the x-ray machine and that the checks were written on PPK’s checking account. As a result, PPK, not Levine, was the real party in interest to assert any claims against Pinski to recover PPK property or monies owed. Accordingly, Levine was not entitled to subtract or set off the $21,500 from the second installment payment owed by Levine, individually, under the Agreement. The circuit court committed reversible error for concluding otherwise.

And that is why Levine could not offset of his personal obligation to Pinski for the amount PPK was injured by Pinski.

Thursday, October 16, 2025

Plumbing Matters; Default Judgment Upheld When Registered Agent Address Insufficient

 Plumbing Matters; Default Judgment Upheld When 
Registered Agent Address Insufficient

The decision of the Kentucky Court of Appeals in Village Square Shopping Center, LLLP v. Hyde, No. 2020-CA-1161-MR, 2021 WL 4228482, 2021 Ky. App. Unpub. LEXIS 545 (Ky. App. Sept. 17, 2021) is an unremarkable slip and fall case that is a significant caution to all companies to be sure the registered agent / office information of record with the Kentucky Secretary of State is complete and accurate.

Jim Hyde suffered a slip and fall in the parking lot of a shopping center owned by Village Square Shopping Center, LLLP, a Kentucky limited partnership (“Village Square”), it managed by National Redevelopment, Inc., an Ohio corporation (“National”).  The accident occurred after exiting a Subway sandwich shop operated by Subway of Middlesboro, Inc. (“Subway Middlesboro”). Hyde filed suit against all three with service to be completed at their respective registered agents as of record with the Secretary of State.  While there were no issues as to service on Subway Middlesboro, the services upon Village Square and National were returned “for insufficient addresses.” Additional efforts to reach at least National by certified mail were not successful.  

In response to its failure to participate in the action, Hyde moved for summary judgment against Subway Middlesboro; that summary judgment was entered on January 14, 2019.  Then on May 29 Hyde (i) moved for a hearing to determine damages to be assessed against Subway Middlesboro and (ii) for a default judgment against Village Square, asserting that “the failure of Village Square to provide a sufficient address for service of process is tantamount to ‘service having been effectuated by estoppel.’”  The court agreed and a default judgment was entered against Village Square. Then, a month after the damages hearing, Hyde moved for a default judgment against National on the basis that his efforts to effect service under the long arm statute (KRS 454.210(3)) were sufficient.  The Circuit Court granted that motion. 

Here is where it gets interesting.  The Circuit Court, by regular USPS mail to Village Square and National, notified them of the default judgment sent to the addresses to which the multiple certified mail communications had been sent. Those letters got through, and each moved to have the default judgments set aside, asserting the had never been served.  That motion was denied, but the damages hearing was reopened to allow Village Center and national  to submit additional evidence as to the damages.  

On appeal, both Village Square and National sought to excuse the ssues with respect to service on each, an effort that failed when “Tellingly, they do ot point to anything Hyde could have done differently to achieve such service.” 2021 WL 4228482, *2-3. Rather:

[I]n accordance with CR 4.04(4), Hyde attempted to serve the partnership of Village Square by having the clerk issue a summons and serve it with a copy of the complaint via certified mail to “an agent authorized by appointment or by law to receive service on its behalf.” Hyde used the name and address Village Square provided to the Secretary of State as its registered agent for service of process. Although there was arguably more Hyde could have done to ensure that Village Square received notice of his complaint, nothing more was required. 2021 WL 4228482, *3.

Addressing who has the burden of making sure the records of the Secretary of State are complete and accurate, the Court went on to note:

It is the duty of partnerships doing business in Kentucky to ensure they have accurately and effectively listed the name and address of their registered agent. Under KRS 362.2-114(1)(b), every “limited partnership shall designate and continuously maintain in this Commonwealth: ... [a] registered office and agent for service of process at that office that comply with KRS 14A.4-010.” (Emphasis added.) This is not optional. Its purpose is to facilitate communication. Listing an address that is insufficient to allow communication, such as service of legal process, does not satisfy this requirement and essentially constitutes fraud by omission. Even so, Village Square contends it had no actual or constructive knowledge4 of these facts. Had Village Square complied with the applicable provisions of KRS 14A.4-010, it undoubtedly would have eventually identified the insufficiency with its listed address. Thus, it may be charged with constructive knowledge under the facts of this case. Id.

. . . .

Appellants assert Village Square did not make any false representations, conceal material facts, or intend to conceal its correct address. However, as previously mentioned, this is a case of fraud by omission. Village Square failed to provide sufficient information to the Secretary of State to allow service of process to reach its registered agent, as evidenced by the return of the certified mail addressed to its agent at the address it provided. Accordingly, the trial court did not err in finding that Hyde complied with his service requirements as to Village Square, and it was equitably estopped from claiming otherwise.  2021 WL 4228482, *4.

Turning to National, it “claim[ed] there was an ‘irregularity’ in how–more specifically to whom–the summons was issued.” The Court of Appeals disposed of that argument by noting it was never raised with the trial court and was therefore waived. 2021 WL 4228482, *4.  From there is was held there no basis for setting aside the default judgment.

I would note that this decision follows numerous others in which default judgments were entered notwithstanding that service through the registered agent could not be accomplished or was subsequently ignored:

  • Bradford White Corp. v. Ky. Farm Bureau Mut. Ins. Co., No. 2013–CA-001549–MR, 2014 Ky. App. Unpub. LEXIS 598 (Ky. App. July 25, 2014) (default judgment not set aside based upon excusable neglect when foreign corporation failed to update information with both the Kentucky and Pennsylvania secretary of state offices). 
  • JP Morgan Chase Bank ex rel. ABFS Mortg. Loan Trust 2003-1 v. Engle, No. 2006-CA-001182-MR, 2007 Ky. App. Unpub. LEXIS 348 (Ky. App. Sept. 21, 2007) (assertion by the defendant that they “somehow misplaced the complaint” not accepted as a valid basis to set aside default judgment).
  • Dakota Enters., Inc. v. Carter, No. 2001-CA-002417-MR, 2003 Ky. App. Unpub. LEXIS 1069 (Ky. App. May 30, 2003) (registered agent’s regular and long term absence from business address not a basis for setting aside default judgment). 
  • Crop Prod. Servs., Inc. v. Williamson, No. 1998-CA-000124-MR, 1999 BL 1452 (Ky. App. June 25, 1999) (default judgment would not be set aside based upon registered agent’s failure to properly forward the complaint to the defendant).
  • Bennche, Inc. v. Silver Creek Transp., LLC, 650 S.W.3d 312 (Ky. Ct. App. 2022) (default judgment not set aside when Texas LLC “did not receive the summons and complaint due to the singular fact that it failed to abide by its obligation to change its registered address with the Texas Secretary of State. The requirement that corporate entities maintain a current registered address and agent for service of process is not a mere formality but is a necessity for the consistent and effective functioning of our governing and regulatory agencies as well as the only means by which parties can effectuate redress with our judiciary.” The Court observing  as well “Carelessness alone does not support a finding of excusable neglect or good cause. Accordingly, we cannot say that the circuit court's determination on this issue was an abuse of discretion.”).


For more on the consequences of a failure to qualify to transact business, see Thomas E. Rutledge & Laura H. Pulliam, Qualification to Transact Business in Kentucky, § 12.07, in Kentucky Business and Commercial Law (forthcoming 2025).

Practice Pointer:  For your primary entity and its subsidiaries in whatever state they may be organized, double check who is the registered agent and the registered address thereof to be sure they are accurate and complete.  Also be sure the registered agent knows who at your company is to be contacted should they receive service of process or other communications addressed to your company. 

Tuesday, October 14, 2025

The Battle of Hastings

                                            The Battle of Hastings


       Today marks the 959th anniversary of the Battle of Hastings.


       1066 has already been a tumultuous year in England. On January 5, Edward the Confessor died, leaving the English throne to Harold Godwinson (King Harold II). Harold’s family, the Godwins, were the most powerful in England. Harold was himself an earl and as well the brother-in-law to Edward the Confessor, the latter having been married to Harold’s daughter Edith. William of Normandy, also known as William the Bastard, claimed that he had been designated as Edward’s successor and that Harold had once promised him that he, Harold, disclaimed any right to the throne, leaving it instead to William. In addition, Harold Hardrada of Norway asserted a claim to the English throne.


       Sometime in September, Harold Hardrada had landed his troops in the north of England. After fast marching his troops north, the army of Harold Godwinson met the invading army of Harold Hardrada (supported by Tostig Godwinson, Harold’s brother) at the Battle of Stamford Bridge. The invading army was defeated, and Hardrada was killed. Learning of William’s invasion in the south, Harold had to turn his army around and fast march it south in order to respond to this new threat. Those forced marches were some 240 miles each way.


       For reasons that have baffled many historians, Harold, upon arriving in London, quickly turned his troops, already exhausted from the march, toward Hastings. He did this notwithstanding that reinforcements were due to arrive the following day. Still, Harold led his forces towards William’s beachhead, leaving word for the reinforcements to catch up as soon as possible. Those reinforcements included the archers.


      The Battle of Hastings proper (there was an earlier skirmish) probably began around 11 in the morning. Through most of the day the forces of Harold prevailed – his forces fought as a phalanx, and  attacks on the shield wall were not effective.  In addition, the Norman archers were not effective firing up-hill. Harold holding his own against William would have been for Harold a win. As observed by Frank McLynn in 1066 - The Year of Three Battles:


[Harold] knew he had only to hold out until nightfall when reinforcements were certain to arrive; he could play for a draw but William had to have a win.


       The Norman infantry having failed to break through, William sent in his calvary. Attacking uphill, they did not have the force necessary to break through. William’s flank (the Breton forces) started to fail and William was unhorsed and rumored to be dead. Thinking (it would appear) that things were going in their favor, Harold’s forces began an advance downhill, their shield wall still intact and functionally invulnerable. But then the advance lost its momentum, perhaps due to the death of its leader Leofwine, Harold’s brother. William’s forces pushed back and in order Harold’s forces reversed themselves back uphill. It was then a battle of attrition, and the Norman invaders were lost at a lower rate than were Harold’s forces. A combined archery and armored calvary assault finally broke the shield wall, and the battle dissolved into a melee between small units. Harold and the remaining troops around him were attacked and Harold fell to multiple sword blows and a lance through his chest.

       

Maybe an hour after Harold fell, reinforcements, including additional housecarls, arrived.

       

The accepted, albeit almost certainly apocryphal, story is that Harold fell after being struck in the eye with an arrow. The Bayeux Tapestry may be interpreted as saying such. However, the “King Harold was killed” heading is over two figures (neither wearing a crown), one with an arrow in his eye and the other being struck down by a sword. If the former is meant to be Harold, the famous arrow in the eye as depicted in the Bayeux Tapestry may be a later invention. It is not mentioned in the earliest accounts of the battle. In addition, in medieval iconography, an arrow in the eye is the punishment afforded a perjurer. Having gone against his oath to leave the throne to William, some might have felt it poetic justice, even if not based in reality.


       By Christmas William was crowned King of England and was in Westminster Abbey accepting pledges of fealty from England’s mobility. Still, the next two decades of his reign would see numerous rebellions and challenges, including one from his own son Robert.

       

As for the Bayeux Tapestry itself, HERE IS A LINK is an animated (and translated) version.

      

The English like to claim that the Norman Invasion was the last invasion of England. This is not true. For example, during the Barons War, a French force invaded and had control of a significant portion of southern England, and the Isle of Wight was invaded in 1545. But the Norman Conquest is the last successful invasion of England.

   

William would reign as king of England until his death in 1087. The definitive biography of William the Conqueror is that by David C. Douglas.


Happy Birthday Sophia of Hanover

 The Birth of Sophia of Hanover and the Descent of the British Crown


     Today is the anniversary of the 1630 birth of Sophia of Hanover, sometimes referred to as Sophia of the Palatinate. Probably you have never heard of her. She is, however, the reason the current British royal family is what it is. 


     In the late 18th century, the succession to the British throne was in controversy. The direct lines were childless. The most adjacent lines were Catholic, and the political decision had been made that only a Protestant could sit on the throne. Under “An Act for the Further Limitation of the Crown and Better Securing the Rights and Liberties of the Subject,” better known as the “Act of Settlement of 1701,”  the line of succession was placed upon a cadet line of descendants of James I, they being Protestant. James I, the first Stuart on the British throne, was the son of Mary Queen of Scots, she being the daughter of Mary of Guise and James V of Scotland.  In turn, James V was the son of Scotland’s James IV and Margaret Tudor, she being the daughter of Henry VII (and the sister of Henry VIII).


         The Act of Settlement declared in part that: 


Therefore for a further Provision of the Succession of the Crown in the Protestant Line We Your Majesties most dutifull and Loyall Subjects the Lords Spirituall and Temporall and Commons in this present Parliament assembled do beseech Your Majesty that it may be enacted and declared and be it enacted and declared by the Kings most Excellent Majesty by and with the Advice and Consent of the Lords Spirituall and Temporall and Commons in this present Parliament assembled and by the Authority of the same That the most Excellent Princess Sophia Electress and Dutchess Dowager of Hannover Daughter of the most Excellent Princess Elizabeth late Queen of Bohemia Daughter of our late Sovereign Lord King James the First of happy Memory be and is hereby declared to be the next in Succession in the Protestant Line to the Imperiall Crown and Dignity of the forsaid Realms of England France and Ireland with the Dominions and Territories thereunto belonging after His Majesty and the Princess Anne of Denmark and in Default of Issue of the said Princess Anne and of His Majesty respectively.(12  and 13 Will 3 C. 2). 


      Sophia would die (June 8, 1714) two months too soon to ever become the queen of England. Rather, the crown would be placed on the head of her son, George I, the first of the house of Hanover to sit on the English throne. It is from Sophia of Hanover that the current British royal family claims succession to that throne.



Monday, October 13, 2025

The Beginning of the End for the Knights Templar

                                    The Beginning of the End for the Knights Templar


      Today marks the anniversary of the widespread arrest in 1307 throughout France of the members of the Order of Poor Fellow-Soldiers of Christ and Temple of Solomon, better known as the Knights Templar.


      Founded shortly after the First Crusade as a monastic order, the mission of the Templars was to provide protection to pilgrims coming to the Holy Land and otherwise protect the Latin Kingdom.  Eventually the Order developed a rather sophisticated banking organization.  For example, one proposing to travel from England to the Holy Land could deposit funds with the Templars in England, receiving in return what was essentially a letter of credit against which the individual could make withdrawals as they travelled through Europe and ultimately to the Holy Lands.  The military component of the Order, although not large in actual numbers (never more than 1,500 to 2,000 knights), was considered highly effective – after the Battle of Hattin, Saladin ordered the execution of all captured Templars.


      With the eventual loss of the Holy Land territories by the turn of the 14th century, the Templars were without a reason for existence.  At the same time, Philip IV of France, anxious to address a depleted royal treasury by expropriating Templar property and as well exterminate his substantial debts to the Order, fabricated numerous salacious allegations against the Templars, leading to their mass arrest on October 13, 1307.  Ultimately Pope Clement V, then resident in Avignon and largely a pawn of the French crown, issued a bull directing that Templars, wherever located, should be arrested.  The remnants of the Order, other than those executed on spurious charges of heresy, were eventually either pensioned or absorbed into other military orders such as the Knights Hospitaller or the Teutonic Knights.


      A papal finding (a/k/a the Chinon parchment) determined that the Templars were not guilty of the many charges against them including idolatry and heresy.  Their actual failing was having lost their mission while being at least perceived as being wealthy while a king needed funds.  Those assertions are in many instances questionable – a detailed review of the inventories of the English properties of the order demonstrated a far less than extravagant lifestyle. Although the Templars would be found innocent of heresy, as a political concession the Order was dissolved in 1312, its properties turned over to the Knights Hospitaller.  That group would evolve and in the view of some devolve into what is today the Knights of Malta (they have no military function).


      Notwithstanding the efforts of numerous modern authors, the Templars did not possess the Holy Grail, irrespective of whether that was a physical cup or, as suggested in one particularly fanciful book, an oblique reference to Mary Magdalene and, ultimately, the line of Merovingian kings. Ignore the movies as well – Guy de Lusignan was not, as “The Kingdom of Heaven” would have you believe, a Templar. A well written introduction to the history is The Templars by Piers Paul Read.  The books by Malcolm Barber are as well worthwhile.


        Philip IV's moniker is “the Fair”; who says history does not have a sense of irony?


Friday, October 10, 2025

Limited Liability is Not Lost When a Foreign LLC Fails to Qualify to Transact Business

 Limited Liability is Not Lost When a Foreign LLC Fails to Qualify to Transact Business

In Schneider v. Buttermilk Shopping Center, LLC, No. 2024-CA-1036-MR, __ S.W.3d __, 2024 WL 2679049, 2025 Ky. App. LEXIS 77 (Ky. App. Sept. 19, 2025), a recent decision of the Kentucky Court of Appeals, reversed the trial court’s determination the sole member of a foreign (Ohio) LLC did not enjoy limited liability when the LLC transacted business in Kentucky without having first qualified to transact business.

Velvet Smoke BBQ, LLC, an Ohio LLC, leased space in Cresent Springs, Kentucky from Buttermilk Shopping Center, LLC from which it operated a restaurant.  Velvet Smoke was owned by Matthew Schneide; he guaranteed the obligations under the initial but not subsequent terms.  While it was clearly transacting business in Kentucky, Velvet Smoke never “qualified” to transact business in Kentucky. See KRS ch 14A.9. The restaurant went under during a renewal term, and Buttermilk sued to collect monies owed under the lease.

On summary judgment the Kenton Circuit Court held that Schneider did not enjoy limited liability as to the debts and obligations of Velvet Smoke because it never qualified to transact business in Kentucky. In doing so it relied upon KRS §275.095, it providing, inter alia, that a person purporting to act on behalf of a non-existent LLC or outside the scope of their actual authority to act is personally liable on the debts and obligations that arise.  Bear in mind that this statute simply repeats and codifies existing agency law. 

This determination was reversed by the Court of Appeals, it parsing the provisions as to the requirement to qualify and the statutory imposed consequences thereof (a per diem fine and no ability to initiate and maintain an action in Kentucky’s courts) as well as the effect of qualification, one of which is that Kentucky may not consequent thereto regulate the internal affairs of the foeign organization, a set that includes limited liability. It held as well that KRS § 275.095 was not applicable as Velvet Smoke did validly exist as an Ohio organized LLC.

Curiously, the Court of Appeals (perhaps because the question was not addressed by the Circuit Court below) did not investigate the Ohio LLC Act to determine whether it provided Schneider limited liability when acting outside of Ohio. BTW, it does. See Ohio Code § 1706.26

For more on the consequences of a failure to qualify to transact business, see Thomas E. Rutledge & Laura H. Pulliam, Qualification to Transact Business in Kentucky, § 12.04, in Kentucky Business and Commercial Law (forthcoming 2025).

The decision goes on to review the manner in which the landlord applied certain sums between the first least term on which Schneider was a guarantor and the subsequent renewal term for which he was not a guarantor.

Saturday, October 4, 2025

The Swearing in of the Papal Swiss Guard

 The Swearing in of the Papal Swiss Guard


    In most years, on May 6, the anniversary of the day 147 of their number fell while protecting Pope Clement VII during the 1527 Sack of Rome, new members of the Papal Swiss Guard are sworn into their new positions in the world’s smallest standing army.  But this year the ceremony was delayed consequent to the passing of Pope Francis. Today the newest members of the Papal Swiss Guard are being sworn into their new roles. They will be the first to swear to protect a pope from the U.S.