Tuesday, May 8, 2012

Effective Date of Judicial Dissolution


Effective Date of Judicial Dissolution
The existing statutes governing judicial dissolution are confusing as to both the process and the effective date, and for that reason they have been amended by the 2012 General Assembly to provide clarity.
The formula typically employed permitted the court to enter the decree of dissolution, including specifying an effective date of dissolution, with a directive that the decree be then filed with the Secretary of State.  What then would be the effect of a decree of dissolution not filed with the Secretary of State – the statute was silent as to whether this step is a condition precedent to an effective dissolution.  Consider also the notion of an effective date of dissolution that pre-dates entry in the public record.  According to the Secretary of State’s website a particular LLC is in good standing even as, in a trial court’s docket, it has been dissolved.
To avoid these and similar problems, a variety of statutes have been revised to make clear that the filing with the Secretary of State is a necessary step in the judicial dissolution process and to provide specificity as to the effective date, namely the latter of the date of filing by the Secretary of State or the date in the decree of dissolution.
         See 2012 H.B. 341, amending KRS §§ 76, 103, 110 and 123.

Sunday, May 6, 2012

The Sack of Rome


The Sack of Rome
      Today marks the anniversary of the Sack of Rome in 1527 by troops of Charles V, Holy Roman Emperor.

      Since the late 15th Century Italy (or at least the region we today identify as Italy – the notion of the region as a nation was long in the future) had been repeatedly invaded by forces from Northern Europe, each seeking to claim dominion over one area or another.  Rival claimants to the crown of Naples caused as much trouble as did anything, but economic rivalry between for example Genoa and Venice did nothing to calm the waters.
      Charles’ forces were at this point battling the League of Cognac, it being comprised of France, Milan, Venice, Florence and the Papal States (keeping track of the various Leagues through the Italian Wars is a troubling task; the League of Cambrai was initially formed against Venice by the Papacy, France, Spain and the Holy Roman Empire.  Later the initial members would be allied against France with Venice as an ally.  Later Venice and France would be against the Papacy, Spain and the Holy Roman Empire).  After a significant victory over the French army the troops were restive in that they had not been paid – most were mercenary.  Pillaging Rome would be a way of paying the troops.  The city was not well defended, although its formidable walls did need to be and were breached.  Discipline immediately broke down among the troops and a sack of over three days began.
       The Pontifical Swiss Guard, created only in 1506 under Pope Julius II, rose to the occasion.  Of its then number of 189, 147 would fall defending Pope Clement VII, affording him time to take refuge in the Castel Sant’Angelo (Hadrian’s Mausoleum).  New members of the Pontifical Swiss Guard are sworn in on May 6.
      Of course this was not the only sack of Rome – it had fallen many times in its long history.  It fell to the Normans in 1084, in 546 by the Ostrogoths, in 455 by the Vandals, in 410 by the Visigoths and in 387 BC by the Gauls.

Wednesday, May 2, 2012

Resolution of Claims Against Dissolved Company


Martin v. Pack’s Inc. Overruled – Contracts may be Entered
Into on Behalf of a Dissolved Corporation or LLC

      The 2012 General Assembly, by means of H.B. 341, has legislatively overruled the holding of the Kentucky Court of Appeals in Martin v. Pack’s Inc., 358 S.W.2d 481, 2011 WL 3207947 (Ky. App. 2011).  The substance of this decision was previously reviewed on this blog on November 18, 2011.
       Martin v. Pack’s Inc. held, inter alia, that a corporate officer who, after the corporation’s administrative dissolution, entered into, on the corporation’s behalf, an agreement with a third party was personally liable on that obligation, treating, in effect, the corporation as an incapacitated principal.  The net effect of this holding is that one attempting to resolve outstanding claims against a dissolved corporation or LLC does so at their personal peril.
      To address these issues and to avoid future confusion, various of the statutes have been amended to provide that, in the course of dissolution, it is permissible to enter into contracts for the purpose of resolving the liabilities of the dissolving organization.  See 2012 H.B. 341, amending KRS §§ 271B.14-050, 272.325, 273.333 and 275.300.

Monday, April 30, 2012

Anne Boleyn's Fall


The Beginning of the End for Anne Boleyn

      On this day in 1536 Mark Smeaton was arrested, this being the first overt step in Cromwell’s plan to bring down Anne Boleyn.  According to one source, Cromwell had Smeaton brought to his own house and there tortured him.  Eventually, Smeaton would be racked and confess to have committed adultery with Anne Boleyn.  He would ultimately, on May 17, be beheaded at the Tower of London.

Thursday, April 26, 2012

Agreement to Resell Condo for Less than FMV Upheld

Kentucky Court of Appeals Upholds Obligation to
Resell Condominium at Less than Fair Market Value

      In a recent decision, the Kentucky Court of Appeals upheld a deed covenant for a condominium requiring that it be resold to the development at less than its fair market value.  Puckett v. St. Andrews Place Retirement Community, Inc., 2012 WL 1072418 (Ky. App. Mar. 30, 2012) (not to be published). 
      The condominium complex in question is operated by St. Andrews Place Retirement Community, Inc., a nonprofit corporation.  Mary Puckett purchased a condominium for $52,065 in 1993, living in it until she passed away in 2008.  The Master Deed for the property provided that the developer would have a right to re-acquire the property upon its transfer with the price determined on a sliding scale against the original unit cost based upon the number of years of residence.  For someone holding property in excess of ten years, the repurchase would be at 75% of the original cost.  After Ms. Puckett’s death, St. Andrews notified her heirs that it would be buying the property back for $38,588, that being 75% of the original acquisition price of $52,065.  In turn, the heirs refused to sell at less than fair market value and brought a declaratory judgment action seeking the determination that the buyback provision was an unforceable restraint on alienation.  When summary judgment was granted to St. Andrews, the heirs appealed.

      The heirs’ position was based in part on Man O War Restaurant, Inc. v. Martin, 932 S.W.2d 366 (Ky. 1996), wherein the Kentucky Supreme Court invalidated a buyback provision for corporate shares pursuant to which they would be reacquired for the initial acquisition cost, holding that such constituted either an unenforceable penalty or unreasonable liquidated damages.  Curiously absent from the Court’s discussion is any recognition that the Man O War Restaurant has been legislatively overruled by the Kentucky General Assembly.  See, e.g., Rutledge, The 2002 Amendments to the Kentucky Business Corporation Act, 67 Bench & Bar 13 (May, 2003).  The heirs relied as well upon Sebastian v. Floyd, 585 S.W.2d 381 (Ky. 1979), the Court there invalidating a forfeiture clause in an installment land sales contract, it requiring a credit, at the judicial sale, for payments already made by the purchaser.
       Ultimately, the Court held that the buyback would be enforced, it being reasonable in light of the complete disclosure to Ms. Puckett and as well her ultimate heir and the objectives of St. Andrews, namely to provide affordable housing facilities.

        It remains to be seen whether a similar provision in a non-charitably focused venture would be upheld.

Wednesday, April 25, 2012

The Kentucky Uniform Cooperative Association Act


Kentucky Uniform Limited Cooperative Association Act

On March 23, Governor Beshear signed 2012 H.B. 441, it setting forth the enactment of the Kentucky Uniform Limited Cooperative Association Act. 

Tuesday, April 24, 2012

Beware Greeks Bearing Gifts


Beware Greeks Bearing Gifts

      Today marks the anniversary of the traditional Fall of Troy in 1184 B.C., thereby bringing to its culmination the Trojan War.
      The Fall of Troy is not recounted in Homer’s Iliad, the iconic epic, it rather covering only a period of ten days to two weeks within the supposed ten-year span of the war.  The Fall of Troy through the subterfuge of the Trojan Horse is briefly mentioned in the Odyssey and is referenced in several other Greek sources.  The story would not find, however, its full development until Virgil’s Aeneid.
      Some modern historians have attempted to explain the story as an analogy, suggesting actually that an earthquake – Poseidon, whose portfolio included horses, was as well the god of earthquakes.  I, for one, would rather retain the literal interpretation.